Skip to main content

Access to Justice Book

------ The Book America's Small Business Needs

Access

to

Justice

Why the Court’s are closed to small businesses — and why its costing America its future.

----Read An Excerpt

400 $/hr

AVG ATTORNEY HOURLY RATE

$100K

Min. Cost of Commercial Trial

91%

Civil Cases With Unrepresented Party

0

Constitutional Right to Civil Counsel

--------The Problem

Justice has become a

luxury -

and America's

entrepreneurs are paying

the price.

There is a foundational promise embedded in the American legal system: that every person and every business has equal access to the courts. That the law protects the small as readily as it protects the powerful. That a contract breach, a stolen trademark, or a fraudulent partner can be remedied through the judicial system regardless of the size of your balance sheet.

That promise has been quietly broken. The cost of litigation in the United States has reached levels that make the courts effectively inaccessible to the vast majority of small businesses. A routine commercial dispute — the kind that large corporations resolve with a call to in-house counsel — can cost a small business owner hundreds of thousands of dollars and years of distraction before a single substantive hearing.

“The courthouse door is technically open to everyone. The price of admission is another matter entirely.”

— Access to Justice, Chapter One

This book tells the story of how that happened, who benefits from it, who is harmed by it, and what must change. Because when entrepreneurs can’t enforce their rights, can’t defend themselves, and can’t access the institutions designed to protect them — the entire economy suffers the consequences.

I

The Luxury of Litigation

How the hourly billing model, discovery costs, and procedural complexity have transformed the American courthouse from a public institution into a private marketplace — one accessible only to those who can afford to wait.

Read more

II

The Goliath Strategy

The documented playbook through which large corporations weaponize legal costs against small business opponents — using delay, discovery burden, and the sheer cost of fighting to achieve outcomes without ever reaching a verdict on the merits.

Read more

III

Civil Gideon & the Right to Courts

The unfinished constitutional revolution: how the right to counsel established for criminal defendants has never been extended to civil matters — and why the Civil Gideon movement argues it must be, especially for commercial disputes

Read more

------ Civil Gideon - The Central Reform

The Right to

be heard

in Court

In 1963, the Supreme Court held in Gideon v. Wainwright that criminal defendants have the right to appointed counsel. It was a watershed moment — the recognition that legal representation is not a luxury but a constitutional necessity in proceedings where liberty is at stake. Six decades later, no equivalent protection exists for civil matters. Access to Justice argues that this gap must be closed — and makes the legal and economic case for extending Gideon to commercial disputes.

REFORM 01
Right to Civil Counsel
Extend appointed counsel protections to small business commercial disputes below a defined value threshold, treating access to courts as a constitutional right rather than a market commodity.
REFORM 02
Litigation Fee Reform
Implement fee-shifting and loser-pays provisions that deter bad-faith litigation by well-resourced parties designed solely to exhaust and overwhelm smaller opponents.
REFORM 03
Accessible Dispute Forums
Dramatically expand small claims jurisdiction, establish fast-track commercial tribunals, and support technology-enabled ADR that doesn’t require prohibitive counsel fees to navigate.
REFORM 04
Legal Market Transparency
Mandate pricing transparency in legal services, encourage alternative fee arrangements, and create public legal resource infrastructure modeled on proven international frameworks.
THE LARGER ARGUMENT

When Law
Fails Small
Business,
All of Us
Lose

Small businesses account for 99.9% of all US firms, nearly half of all private-sector employment, and a disproportionate share of innovation and economic mobility. They are not a peripheral feature of the American economy — they are its engine. And that engine is being quietly strangled by a legal system that has priced them out of their own rights.

Access to Justice makes the economic case alongside the legal one: that an equitable, accessible legal system is not just a matter of fairness, it is a prerequisite for the kind of dynamic, entrepreneurial economy the United States needs to compete and grow.

THE INACCESSIBILITY IMPACT
Small businesses that forgo legal action due to cost
78%
Average cost of a basic commercial lawsuit
$91K
Ratio of Fortune 500 legal spend to SMB annual revenue
10:1
States with any Civil Gideon protections
6
US attorneys per 100,000 people (vs. 7 in UK)
40
Sources: World Justice Project, NCSC, ABA Legal Aid Survey, 2023
ACCESS TO JUSTICE — THE BOOK

Read the Case
for Equal Access
to the Courts

A rigorous, essential investigation into how America’s legal system became a private luxury — and the reforms that could restore justice as a public right.